I used to send these out irregularly to various players in PBeM / BBS games. I think the questions are fairly slanted, but it was still amusing...
NOTE: This is completely optional; I prefer honesty to flattery anyday so that I know what to keep and what to change. Your answers here will not be reflected in anyway whatsoever for or against your character; the only thing that should change is my work as GM, unless you're OK with it now.What this is is pretty much a "Gamemaster Comment Card." If you could send this back to me with the answers filled in, I'd appreciate it. In some games, I send a kind of "PC Report Card" back.
So.
Also, always feel free to add your comments on any ruling you make. The more info I have, the more I have to work with and the more I can do with it.
----snip
GM COMMENT CARD
Name of Campaign:
Name of Player: ________________________
Character: __________________
On A Scale of 0 to 4, four being "way excellent," 0 being "lousy",
please rate the GM on the following aspects of his/her game:
1. FREQUENCY: how punctual are the moves processed in regards to your schedule and your frequency in turning them in?
2. NPCs: how well are the NPCs being portrayed? Can you tell one from another easily?
3. CHARACTER CREATION: is your character the character you want it to be? Was designing it cooperative and informative?
4. WORLDVIEW: are you comfortable with the cosmology and precepts you've been exposed to? Do you need more info to function?
5. GM INTERACTION: has the GM been available and sympathetic to your questions and concerns when you've had them?
6. PC RESPONSE: how well are the needs and precepts of your character being addressed (within the responses, not the story)?
7. OVERALL: how happy are you with the game so far? Would you recommend it to your friends? And enemies?
8. [waaaay optional]:
How would you improve the web page?
9. [waaaay optional]:
From what hints you've been given, where do you think the story is going? Have you felt railroaded into any choices your character wouldn't've wanted to make?
10. Please add any additional comments, questions, or notes you feel would make this a better game.
T H A N K S !!!
----snip